On Sunday, November 11, 2018, doctors are reportedly holding a protest in front of Deoksugung Palace, across from Seoul City Hall. Doctors, who should be studying hard and staying by the side of patients in pain, should never have to take to the streets. And yet I, too, plan to join tomorrow.

 

Medicine Is a Science, and Still Largely Uncharted Territory

Everyone makes mistakes. Doctors are human. So doctors make mistakes too. And doctors cannot save everyone who is going to die. Why is there a misdiagnosis rate? Many people mistakenly believe it is because doctors lack skill or are negligent.

For example, how high does a tumor marker level in the blood have to be before cancer is diagnosed? The distribution and average of tumor marker levels differ between healthy people and people with cancer. But the two overlap to some extent, and depending on which threshold (cut-off value) is chosen for diagnosing cancer, sensitivity and specificity change, and so does the accuracy of the test. If the threshold is too low, there are more positive diagnoses and therefore more false positives. If it is too high, there are more negative diagnoses and false negatives increase. That is why there is always a margin of error in diagnosis.

The reliability of a particular medical device is assessed by measuring its sensitivity and specificity, and when a device is manufactured, this is measured by comparing it with the method regarded as the gold standard.

 

ROC1 (1).png

Sensitivity: the probability that a person who actually has the disease tests positive
Specificity: the probability that a person who does not have the disease tests negative
Accuracy: Sensitivity + Specificity / 2

 

Sensitivity_Fig_3.jpg

Let us assume that, when it comes to diagnosing disease, a doctor is also a kind of diagnostic machine. With enough evidence and test results, accuracy increases, but there will always be false positives and false negatives in diagnosis. To begin, let us assume that a particular machine or doctor has a sensitivity of 0.95 and a specificity of 0.95 for a particular disease.

Suppose one disease is common, with 40,000 patients per 100,000 people, and another is uncommon, with 2,000 patients per 100,000 people.

 

Sensitivity_Fig_3.jpg

When 40,000 out of 100,000 people (40%) have Disease A, if a device or doctor with 95% accuracy gives a positive diagnosis, the probability that the person truly has the disease is about 92.7%.

 

Sensitivity_Fig_4.jpg

When 2,000 out of 100,000 people (2%) have Disease B, if a device or doctor with 95% accuracy gives a positive diagnosis, the probability that the person truly has the disease drops to about 27.9%.

For Disease B, with a prevalence of about 2%, when a device or doctor with 95% accuracy diagnoses cancer, only about 27.9% of those cases are actually cancer — that much misdiagnosis occurs — and 4,900 out of every 100,000 people will undergo additional examinations and treatment.

 

Screening Tests

Sensitivity_Fig_5.jpg

When 326.2 out of 100,000 people (0.33%) have breast cancer, if a device or doctor with 95% accuracy gives a positive diagnosis, the probability that it is truly cancer is only about 5.9%; on the other hand, a negative result can be trusted almost 100%.

In 2015, the prevalence of breast cancer in Korea was 326.2 per 100,000 people. When screening with mammography of 95% accuracy, the posterior probability is only 5.9%. In addition, there are 4,984 false positives and about 16 missed cases, so even when the result is positive, 94% are not cancer, and a negative result is not 100% either. That is why screening tests use methods that are as sensitive as possible, inexpensive, and simple.

In other words, no matter how skilled the doctor, if the accuracy of a positive diagnosis for a rare disease is below 50%, it has no value and the result should not simply be accepted. Of course, people who test negative can be confident they do not have the disease, so it cannot be said that the test is not worth taking. But patients who receive a false-positive diagnosis will need additional tests for confirmation, and most of those results will come back negative. In the end, to avoid missing the disease in a small number of patients, the people with false positives become victims who undergo unnecessary tests.

However, the value of a screening test lies in narrowing the target group from a total of 100,000 people down to 5,294. The 5,294 people who screened positive then undergo further testing for a definitive diagnosis. This time, tests with the highest possible specificity are chosen. These are usually expensive and complex, but by reducing false positives as much as possible, a positive result can accurately indicate that the disease is truly present.

 

On the Judge's Decision to Jail Doctors over the Scientific Error Inherent in Diagnosis

In 2015, Korea had 2.3 million people aged 5 to 10, and reportedly 2 of them were diagnosed with acquired diaphragmatic hernia.

 

Sensitivity_Fig_6.jpg

In normal practice, a total of 115,000 people would be judged positive, and fewer than 2 of them would actually have the disease, so the probability that a person with a positive diagnosis truly has it is close to 0%. The remaining 115,000 false positives would have to be admitted to hospital and undergo CT scans for confirmation. In that situation, even if there were findings suggestive of diaphragmatic hernia, the chance of being wrong was higher, so it was a reasonable decision for the doctor to send home a patient whose symptoms had improved.

Acquired diaphragmatic hernia is an extremely rare disease. In Korea, its prevalence is about 1 in 1 million people. That means even if a highly skilled and reliable machine or doctor gives a positive diagnosis, the probability that it is a false positive — that is, wrong — is higher. Even so, if a doctor, confident in his own skill, admitted everyone suspected of diaphragmatic hernia and ordered CT scans, the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service of Korea's national health insurance system would brand him a money-seeking doctor engaged in fraudulent and excessive treatment, and the doctor would have to pay back all the costs.

So even though there was such a finding on the X-ray, the probability of it being a true case was nearly 0%. The doctor therefore diagnosed constipation, the most common cause of abdominal pain in that age group, gave an enema, and sent the patient home after the symptoms improved. This is a diagnostic approach that every doctor has internalized.

The judge who jailed the doctors in this case must apologize to doctors. And the state must compensate doctors for the harm done.

 

The Usefulness of Regular Breast Cancer Screening for Women Aged 50 and Over

In fact, a study by the international Cochrane Collaboration of more than 600,000 people aged 50 and over found that with regular breast cancer screening, 4 per 1,000 people died of breast cancer over 10 years, while without screening, 5 per 1,000 died over 10 years.

The conclusion is that breast cancer screening improved mortality by about 0.1%, while producing about 100 false positives per 1,000 people, leading to additional unnecessary biopsies. For this reason, regular breast cancer screening is not performed in Europe, whereas in Korea the National Health Insurance Service provides it.

Dr. Jung, Director, Venus Clinic


  1. Diet First, or Liposuction First? — Why the Result Can Be Disappointing After You Have Already Lost the Weight

    Diet First, or Liposuction First? — Why the Result Can Be Disappointing After You Have Already Lost the Weight In the consultation room, I hear these questions very often: “I was told to lose some weight first. Do I have to?” and “Isn't it b...
    Read More
  2. Arm Liposuction: Why Does the Cost Vary by Treatment Area?

    Arm Liposuction: Why Does the Cost Vary by Treatment Area? When considering arm liposuction, it is difficult to compare procedures by the name “whole arm” and price alone. The areas treated differ depending on whether the plan includes only ...
    Read More
  3. Double Chin Liposuction vs. Lifting Devices: Which Fits Your Chin?

    Double Chin Liposuction vs. Lifting Devices: Which Fits Your Chin? In consultations, we often hear the question, "I'm bothered by my double chin. Would a lifting device be enough, or should I have liposuction?" It can be a hard choice betwee...
    Read More
  4. Comparing Abdominal Liposuction Costs by Surgical Area

    Comparing Abdominal Liposuction Costs by Surgical Area In consultations, we often hear questions such as “Is it enough to treat just the belly, or should the flanks be done too?” and “Why does the cost of abdominal liposuction differ so much...
    Read More
  5. Breast Fat Grafting ② Absorption and Additional Grafting After Breast Fat Grafting — How Much Remains, and When Is It Refilled

    Breast Fat Grafting ② Absorption and Additional Grafting After Breast Fat Grafting — How Much Remains, and When Is It Refilled In breast fat grafting consultations, I often hear questions like these. "Will all of the fat that is put in stay?...
    Read More
  6. Accessory-Breast Area Liposuction: How Much Can It Reduce the Bulge Above a Bra?

    Accessory-Breast Area Liposuction: How Much Can It Reduce the Bulge Above a Bra? Many people tell us they are bothered by a bulge between the outer edge of their bra cup and the front of the armpit. It may look more prominent with the arms a...
    Read More
  7. [Case Review] Sagging Breasts: Liposuction or Fat Grafting?

    [Case Review] Sagging Breasts: Liposuction or Fat Grafting? In the clinic, we often hear the question, "My breasts sag. Should I have liposuction or fat grafting?" Even for the same breast ptosis (sagging breasts), the sagging can be improve...
    Read More
  8. Thigh Liposuction and Buttock Liposuction: Surgical Areas and Cost

    Thigh Liposuction and Buttock Liposuction: Surgical Areas and Cost In consultations, we often hear questions such as "Is it enough to treat only the thighs?" and "Why do buttock liposuction and thigh liposuction cost differently?" Even under...
    Read More
  9. Breast Fat Grafting ① Using Your Own Fat Instead of Implants — Who Is It Suited For, and How Far Can It Go?

    Breast Fat Grafting ① Using Your Own Fat Instead of Implants — Who Is It Suited For, and How Far Can It Go? During consultations, I often hear, "I'm hesitant about implants. Can't my breasts be filled with my own fat?" Many patients are trou...
    Read More
  10. Can Abdominal Liposuction Lift a Sagging Belly? — [Case Review] Circumferential Liposuction Through the Bra-Line Back, Waist, and Flanks

    Can Abdominal Liposuction Lift a Sagging Belly? — [Case Review] Circumferential Liposuction Through the Bra-Line Back, Waist, and Flanks In the clinic, we often hear, “My belly sags and folds down over my waistband,” and “If I have abdominal...
    Read More
Board Pagination Prev 1 2 3 4 5 ... 10 Next
/ 10